This is Part IV of my series of posts relating to the Japanese cultural phenomenon called “ero-guro-nansensu”, or erotic-grotesque-nonsense. Part III, which discussed Teruo Ishii’s “pinky violent” contribution to the ero-guro landscape entitled Horrors of Malformed Men, is found here.
Midori — The Girl in the Freak Show
(a.k.a. Shôjo tsubaki: Chika gentô gekiga).
1992, directed and animated by Hiroshi Harada
Much like Teruo Ishii’s Horrors of Malformed Men, a great deal has been made about the banned status of Hiroshi Harada’s 1992 anime Midori — The Girl in the Freak Show, and similarly, the details concerning its banned notoriety are rather murky. This film has screened at a small number of festivals, but is unavailable on DVD in both the Japanese and North American markets. It is only available through a small DVD distributor in France called CinéMalta. To a large extent, the film has been buried due to ongoing issues with the Japanese censors, and Harada has simply chosen not to screen it in his native country. In a videotaped interview that was included as an extra on the Midori DVD, Harada stated candidly:
“The situation in Japan makes it very difficult for films like mine to enter the mainstream. Hayao Miyazaki is well-known in Japan, and his films are seen abroad. If his stories represent the official story of Japan, then “Midori” is a counter-story of Japan, one the Japanese State and powers that be have suppressed and tried to hide away.”
Due to the controversial nature of the content, Harada was unable to secure investors for the project. Thus, he financed and worked on the 52-minute film alone, creating all of the artwork over a 5-year period using the technique of cel animation. This explains, in part, the somewhat limited nature of the animation – i.e. some scenes being just a succession of still images with camera holds, pans and zooms.
Midori is a very faithful adaption of artist Suehiro Maruo’s underground manga entitled Mr. Arashi’s Amazing Freak Show (published in 1984, now out-of-print) that tells the story of an abused flower girl in 1920’s Japan. When Midori, a poor girl about the age of 12, is suddenly and tragically orphaned, she seeks the help of one of her former customers, the mysterious Bowler Hat Man, who had previously extended an offer of assistance. Unfortunately, it is soon revealed that the The Bowler Hat Man has tricked the naïve Midori into becoming a virtual slave for a travelling circus show, where he inhabits the role of impresario. Thus begins the bleak tale of Midori’s cruel mistreatment and repeated rape by the grotesque monsters that work the carny sideshow.
Both Maruo’s manga and Harada’s film adaptation are populated by a now familiar set of erotic-grotesque stock characters — the carny sideshow impresario and his collection of “freaks” including the magician dwarf, the hermaphrodite, and a limbless performer similar to the “human caterpillar” (which reminds us of Rampo’s short story). Several forms of sexual fetishism are on display, and in particular the fetish of eyeball-licking (called oculolinctus, by the way), which is a favourite motif for Maruo.
Midori opens with a succession of images that flash quickly across the screen, accompanied by different voices that seem to call out a disconnected, nonsensical stream of words. According to Harada, these strangely poetic phrases are the sort you’d hear from carnival barkers back in the 1920’s.
If you’re a fan of Anime, and particularly the more underground and darker examples of the genre, then Midori is definitely worth tracking down. It’s not an easy viewing – and it does have a relentlessly bleak ending—but it is a very faithful adaptation of Maruo’s “ero guro” classic and effectively conveys the very limited options available to a young girl without the benefit (or protection) of a family or husband in 1920’s Japan. WARNING: some animated puppies are squashed.
You can view the entire film here, at least for now.
My next post in this ongoing series on ero-guro-nansensu discusses one of the most notorious Japanese films ever made, In the Realm of the Senses (1976), directed by Nagisa Oshima.
6 thoughts on “Deviant Desires: Erotic Grotesque Nonsense, Part IV: “Midori — The Girl in the Freak Show””
Loved the book, looking forward to finally seeing the animated version.
Enjoy! There’s been a couple of full versions of the film floating around on Youtube (like the link above), but don’t wait too long. They tend to get pulled down after a while.
It is always interesting to note how there is a massive amount of underground manga, but not nearly as much underground anime. Back when there existed the market for OAVs you would get weird stuff like Belladona of Sadness or the Sensualist, but now that market almost doesn’t even exist. Considering how anime is made through the efforts of countless workers, this does make perfect sense. Now I don’t have a proper source for this, but I have always heard that Hiroshi Hirada essentially made this anime all by himself, doing all the in between and key frame animation.
On an unrelated note; the anime Ranpo Kitan: Game of Laplace is still a wonderfully bizarre adventure in modernizing Ero Guro storytelling.
True, there really is so very little underground anime. The high budgets of animation projects could be a factor. Ironically, these days it’s easier than ever to create animation with relatively cheap digital tools, so you’d think that niche animation projects like “Midori” would thrive rather than be scarce.
Yes, Harada created all of the artwork and animation for “Midori”, though he hired others to photograph it. Impressive feat!
Pingback: Deviant Desires: Erotic Grotesque Nonsense, part III. “Horrors of Malformed Men” (1969). | Lady Lazarus: dying is an art
Pingback: Deviant Desires: Erotic Grotesque Nonsense, Part V: “In the Realm of the Senses” | Lady Lazarus